Select A Product

And Get Started

Reuter & Reilly Insurance

Reuter & Reilly Insurance is proud to continue our tradition of service excellence in the Niagara Peninsula close to 100 years. Our mission is to present our clients with a broad choice of insurance products and services in a professional, knowledgeable and friendly manner. Our Welland-based, full-service insurance brokerage offers clients a wide range of insurance solutions including: home & auto insurance, marine, commercial insurance, life insurance and group benefits.

Why Choose Reuter & Reilly

Fast and Easy

Save time! Get an Insurance Quote in minutes.

Save Money

We can get you the best possible rates!

You're Covered

100-years of experience behind every policy written.

We will work with you to ensure you fully understand your options and make sound insurance decisions.

Jeff Reuter, President

Refer a client and win up to $300


Hear what clients have said:
Best Customer Service

Thank you Teresa! This has been a fantastic overall experience. I really appreciate your advice, promptness and professionalism.

Taylor R&R Insurance Client
New Home Buyer

“I’m purchasing my first home, and I decided to stay with you guys and get the proper coverage I need.”

New Customer

"I feel like I have to tell you that we LOVE your office! They have been wonderful!  I’m so glad we changed!”

Best Customer Service

I will for sure in the future, continue to spread the good word to friends and family. For years now we have received the best customer service from Reuter & Reilly and are grateful.

Patty F R&R Insurance Client

Partners & Associates

Aviva logo
180 gore mutal
intact insurance
Portage Mutual Insurance Logo
RSA Insurance Logo